PPC Ian

PPC Ian

Dividend Investing For Everyone

  • Home
  • About PPC Ian
  • My Dividend Stock Portfolio
  • Sin Stock Investing Guide
  • Stock Analysis Worksheet
  • Yield On Cost Worksheet
You are here: Home / Random / The Ministry of Truth in Advertising

The Ministry of Truth in Advertising

By Guest Blogger Mar 3 0

David RodnitzkyHey Everyone,
PPC Ian here. I’m honored today to share a guest post for you from my good friend David Rodnitzky, CEO of PPC Associates. What is PPC Associates? It’s Silicon Valley’s SEM Agency. David just spoke at SMX West 2012 and did an amazing job! Without further ado, let’s jump into today’s guest post…
All the best,
Ian

The hero in George Orwell’s 1984 has a simple job: rewriting history. He scours over old newspapers (at the direction of the ironically named “Ministry of Truth”) and changes stories to make it appear that the government is doing an incredible job. For example:

PPC Associates

As short a time ago as February, the Ministry of Plenty had issued a promise (a ‘categorical pledge’ were the official words) that there would be no reduction of the chocolate ration during 1984. Actually, as Winston was aware, the chocolate ration was to be reduced from thirty grammes to twenty at the end of the present week. All that was needed was to substitute for the original promise a warning that it would probably be necessary to reduce the ration at some time in April.

To the citizens of Oceana – whose only source of information is the government – this ongoing manipulation of the truth creates a sense of incredible progress:

The fabulous statistics continued to pour out of the telescreen. As compared with last year there was more food, more clothes, more houses, more furniture, more cooking-pots, more fuel, more ships, more helicopters, more books, more babies — more of everything except disease, crime, and insanity. Year by year and minute by minute, everybody and everything was whizzing rapidly upwards.

You might wonder, what does this have to do with search engine marketing? Well, a lot, actually, and the fact that you don’t immediately recognize it as such only further proves my point!

Consider the following changes to AdWords over the last few years and see if you notice any similarities:

  1. The addition of many-per-click conversions;
  2. The addition of view-through conversion tracking;
  3. The addition of multi-channel funnel reporting in Google Analytics;
  4. The addition of “top versus side” reporting;
  5. The addition of “impression share” reporting;
  6. The addition of “minimum first page bid” reporting.

To me, all of these reports serve one purpose: to convince you to spend more money with less regard for your actual ROI. Take view-through tracking, a metric that counts a conversion when a user sees – but does not click on – a display ad and later converts at your site. Do you have any proof that this user was influenced by the display ad? Generally, no – but Google wants you to think twice about disabling display ads with no actual conversions but plenty of “view through” conversions.

Top versus side reporting is another example. Mike Nelson wrote an awesome post outlining how to use top versus side reporting to improve your ROI, but I suspect that most AdWords users see too much “side” position as an affront to their manhood and spend more per click not to increase performance but to increase their own vanity.

It’s worth noting that tools like multi-channel funnel and view-throughs never existed in AdWords or Analytics until Google decided to snap up DoubleClick and YouTube. Suddenly, last-click data (i.e. paid search) needed to share the spotlight with first-click data (display, video, etc.). No doubt if Google+ takes off, we can expect to see a lot more integration of “social conversions” into AdWords and Analytics.

Google’s long-term plan is to create a single dashboard that integrates AdWords, YouTube, Analytics, Google Affiliate Network, DoubleClick Display, and Mobile in one place. Perhaps this will be given to advertisers for free (like Analytics and AdWords currently are), or perhaps this will have a nominal fee associated with it (like ad serving or campaign management through DoubleClick). Either way, the true benefit to Google will be the ability to control how advertisers determine success.

As long as Google controls the reporting and analytics, Google can heavily influence how advertisers measure success. As such, as new Google products and channels roll out, Google can increase advertiser adoption by creating new metrics that validate investment in these products.

Now, before I get an agitated call from one our fabulous AdWords reps (thanks for the cupcakes last week, Elizabeth!), I want to note that I don’t blame Google for trying to influence advertisers through their reporting tools. As noted, all of these tools can be incredibly useful for advertisers if applied properly, and it’s hard to argue with the price!

If anything, the point of this post is to caution advertisers to think carefully about how you define success, rather than blindly accepting what your vendors – Google or otherwise – tell you is a winning strategy. There are lies, damn lies, and statistics. At the end of the day, the one metric that never lies is profit. View-throughs, cost per engagement, virality coefficients, and other fancy stats are all interesting enough, but you can’t pay the bills with them. Focus on profit, and no ministry of truth can ever deceive you!

David Rodnitzky is the CEO and co-founder of PPC Associates, a digital-marketing firm with offices in the Bay Area and Chicago. He can be contacted at info@ppcassociates.com.

All images in this post © PPCAssociates.com

Tags: david rodnitzky, ppc metrics Categories: Random

Prev
Next

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About PPC Ian

Ian Lopuch (PPC Ian)Hi, I'm Ian Lopuch, also known as PPC Ian. I'm an Idaho-based real estate developer and investor, with an incredible passion for dividend stocks (and investments that provide true passive income for the long-term). In fact, I have built a portfolio of 37 positions that will one day pay for all of my living expenses. I enjoy blogging here about my passion for cash flow investing, while also sharing some other business and digital marketing insights from time-to-time.

Read More About PPC Ian

My Valued Sponsors

Advertise Here     Advertise Here

Let’s Talk Stocks

Watch My YouTube Videos See My Photos On Instagram Tweet Me on Twitter Like Me on Facebook Network With Me on LinkedIn

PPC Ian Tag Cloud

3q digital acquisio ad copy adlift admedia adwords affiliate marketing bid management bing blog anniversary blog commenting charity digital marketing dividend dividends domaining ebay partner network facebook ads facebook advertising goals google google adwords ian lopuch kenshoo lending club marin software mentor box mentorbox ppc associates ppc automation ppc career ppc jobs public speaking search alliance sem agency sem automation sem career sem software seo smx smx west stanford gsb weekend musings yahoo youtube

Posts By Category

PPC Ian Dividends Yield On Cost

My Favorite Dividend Stocks For 2018 and Beyond

Check This Out These Are Dividend Checks

I Invest For Dividends and Financial Freedom

Ian Lopuch Carmel CA

Angel Investing: My Experience With SAFE Agreements

The Five Minute Journal

The Five Minute Journal: My Review and Experience

Mentor Box

My Mentorbox Review

PPC Ian at Stanford Graduate School of Business

PPC Ian Presents at Stanford GSB Again

Stanford GSB Presentation

Video: Stanford Graduate School of Business

Net

Buying Domains on Sedo

BlueHost Web Hosting

BlueHost, Add-On Domains, and .htaccess

PPC Ian
Follow on
Twitter
Connect on
Facebook
  • Home
  • About PPC Ian
  • Consulting
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Me
Copyright © 2009 through 2025 PPCIan.com (An IJL Productions LLC Site). All Rights Reserved.